Table of Contents

Insurance agents are the backbone of the insurance sector, acting as dependable consultants for individuals and companies. 

The insurance agent commission structure mainly drives an agent's motivation, and these commissions can be said to be their financial backbone. 

Here the question may arise, how much commission do insurance agents make?

The answer is that the insurance agent commission varies for each type of insurance and depends on whether the policy is new or a renewal.

Here, you can have a glance at the commission rates for the three main insurance types. According to Insurance Business


First Time 

On Renewal

Health Insurance

5% to 10%

1% to 2%

Life Insurance

40% to 120%

1% to 2%

Home Insurance 

5% to 15%

2% to 5%

These might look simple, but understanding the factors and concepts underlying these commissions gives complete insight into the insurance agent commission.

Read the blog until the end, and you will understand the components, types and factors influencing the commission structures.

What are insurance agent commissions

The insurance agent commission rate is a percentage of the premium that insurance companies pay agents for selling their policies.

It acts as a financial incentive for agents to market, close deals, and provide customer service for insurance to people, companies, or groups. 

The insurance commission may be paid once or on an ongoing basis if the policy is renewed.

Commission structure encourages agents to retain their current clientele while attracting new ones, creating a mutually beneficial relationship between the agent's efforts and pay.

5 Components of insurance commission structures

Here are a few components that you might need to know:

1. Base commission

The basic commission that an agent gets from an insurance company when a policy is successfully sold is base commission. It is the primary source of income an agent receives, irrespective of how well they close deals; a salesperson always gets paid this set amount of money.

2. Renewal commissions

If a client renews their contract, a salesperson receives a renewal commission. This ongoing commission promotes consistent service and encourages agents to uphold long-term client connections.

3. Performance-based bonuses

Extra incentives given to agents in response to hitting predetermined goals, performance benchmarks, or sales targets. These incentives encourage agents to perform above and beyond expectations.

4. Retention bonuses

Bonuses given to agents for retaining customers and making sure policyholders keep their insurance for long periods are retention bonuses. This motivates agents to concentrate on maintaining and satisfying their clientele.

5. Supplementary commissions

Agents who meet certain requirements imposed by the insurance company and sell specialized insurance products are eligible for this additional pay. These additional commissions act as an added incentive for selling particular kinds of policies.

3 Common insurance commission structure

The commission structures of the three insurance sectors, health, life, and home, are each different and structured to meet the needs of the products available in their respective markets. 

Here are the insurance commission rates in the USA for the three common insurance types:

1. Life insurance commission

Life insurance commission structures revolve around compensating agents for selling life insurance policies that provide coverage in the event of death, disability, or other predefined circumstances. 

Life insurance commission rates can fluctuate and may include one-time policy sales commissions and recurring renewal commissions, usually stated as a percentage of the policy's premium.

Generally, a life insurance agent in the USA gets 30% to 90% of the amount paid by the  client in the first year. The agent may get renewals in subsequent years, ranging from 3% to 10% of the annual premium.

2. Health insurance commission 

The commission system for health insurance is to pay salespeople for recommending policies that include hospitalization, treatment, and medical bills.

Even here, the commission structure includes initial sales commissions and commissions for ongoing renewals.

The average health insurance commission rate is between 5% and 10% of the total premiums, and the percentage decreases upon a plan renewal.

3. Home insurance commission 

Commission plans for home insurance reward agents for recommending policies that safeguard homeowners from liability risks, damage to property, and loss of personal possessions.

A portion of the policy premium is usually charged as a commission in the home insurance sector, and it represents the agent's dedication to ensuring that the homeowner's needs are adequately covered.

Independent agents earn roughly 15% of the total premiums given for the first year. Captive agents receive between 5% and 10% of that amount. Irrespective of the kind of agent, commission fees for renewals range from 2% to 15%, with an average of 2% to 5%.

4 Factors influencing commission structures

How does a company decide on its insurance agent commission structure and pay scale?

Below are the factors they take into account:

1. Type of insurance products

The degree of complexity and type of insurance products that are sold have an impact on commission setups. 

Depending on the risks involved and the technicalities of the policies, different insurance categories, such as life, health, and general insurance, may have distinct commission rates and structures.

For instance, life insurance typically has a higher percentage than other insurance kinds of home or property. This is due to the longer-term nature of life insurance.

2. Insurance carrier policies and guidelines

The insurance commission in each state issues licenses to businesses and agents. Regulations, policies and guidelines  may cover things like commission percentages, how agents should be paid, and the structures they can employ.

Based on that, insurance firms set up rules and regulations that specify how and what commission will be paid.

Commission arrangements frequently adapt to changes in the market in this sector. The insurance industry's competitive dynamics may force firms to modify commission rates and provide additional incentives in order to draw and keep qualified agents.

4. Agent experience, tenure, and expertise

Insurance agents' commission rates can be influenced by factors such as experience, longevity, and skill. Agents with more experience and have a track record of achievements in sales may be able to negotiate higher commission rates and be eligible for performance-based bonuses.

How much commission do insurance agents make in the USA

The commission structure for insurance agents in the USA can vary depending on the type of insurance they sell and the insurance company they work for. Generally, insurance agents earn a commission as a percentage of the premiums for the policies they sell. Here are some common commission structures for different types of insurance:

  • Life insurance: Life insurance agents often receive a first-year commission that can range from 50% to 100% of the annual premium. Renewal commissions for subsequent years may be lower, typically around 2% to 5%.
  • Health insurance: Health insurance agents usually earn commissions that range from 3% to 15% of the premium for individual health policies. Group health insurance policies may have lower commission rates.
  • Property and casualty insurance: Agents selling property and casualty insurance, such as auto and homeowners insurance, typically receive commissions ranging from 5% to 20% of the annual premium.
  • Commercial insurance: Agents dealing with commercial insurance policies often earn higher commissions due to the complexity and higher premiums involved. Commissions can range from 10% to 25% or more.

It's important to note that these figures are general estimates, and actual commission rates can vary based on factors such as the insurance company's policies, the agent's experience, the volume of business generated, and any bonuses or incentives offered by the insurance company.

To sum up

Knowing about the insurance agent commissions' economics highlights the crucial connection between the incentive systems that regulates their pay and how it motivates the agents.

As commission pay being the motivation factor for agents, it becomes critical for insurance companies to handle their agents' pay effectivel.

This is where sales compensation software - Compass emerges as a vital tool.

A Comprehensive solution that streamlines and manages the complexities of commission structures.

Enables insurers to:

👉 effectively calculate, 

👉 track, and 

👉 disburse commissions to their agents

If you want to know more, how exactly Compass can automate your insurance agent commission pay then book the demo now!

Unlock the Biggest Secret of Engagement to Retain your Top Performers.
Learn how

Guest Contributor